Lightroom vs Photoshop: Which One Should I Choose?
If you’re looking for the right editing program, Lightroom and Photoshop should be at the top of your list. These programs are preferred by professional photographers all over the world.
While you can edit photos with either Lightroom or Photoshop, here’s what’s most important to keep in mind.
Photoshop is for perfecting one photo at a time where Lightroom is for editing and organizing hundreds of photos at a time.
Let’s take a closer look at each program.
Editing Features of Lightroom
In a professional photographer’s workflow, Lightroom does most of the heavy lifting.
With Lightroom, you can bulk import hundreds of images at once, cull images, select images for further processing and make all of your basic edits.
In terms of editing features, Lightroom is almost identical to Photoshop’s Camera RAW filter.
The image to the left shows the editing interface of Lightroom (on the left) and the Camera Raw module inside Photoshop.
As you can see, both programs allow you to make the same adjustments:
- White Balance
- And more…
While you can make basic adjustments in either program, there is a reason why most photographers prefer to begin their editing process in Lightroom, not Photoshop.
Bulk Adjustments with Lightroom
The ability to make bulk edits in Lightroom makes it the perfect choice to begin the editing process.
You can select an entire series of imported photos and apply the same edits to each photo at once.
When you have hundreds of photos to process, this is a massive time-saver.
And to save even more time, you can apply these adjustments at the same time you import your photos.
This magic happens with an assist from Lightroom Presets.
Lightroom Presets for Bulk Photo Editing
Lightroom Presets are photo editing recipes that adjust exposure, contrast, saturation, apply gradients and much more. They make all of your photos look like they were edited by a pro…even if you’re an editing novice.
The beauty of a preset is that you don’t have to adjust any sliders yourself unless you want to make a few fine adjustments.
They can be applied to as many photos as you wish when you import your images into Lightroom – and with only a single click!
Needless to say, the ability to edit a large number of photos with a single click cuts hours of editing time down to just seconds.
(Grab some FREE Lightroom Presets to edit your photos in one click here!)
Lightroom’s Organization and Cataloguing Features
Presets aren’t the only reason to use Lightroom.
While Lightroom and Photoshop share many of the same basic photo editing features, Lightroom shines as the best tool for photo management and cataloging.
Lightroom allows you to tag photos with flags, star ratings and keywords.
This means that Lightroom makes it easy for you to find a specific photo in the future, instead of spending hours sorting through images.
Lightroom even allows you to create entirely different image catalogues to make photo management even easier.
You can also set up Lightroom to publish directly to online services like Flickr and Facebook.
Apart from Lightroom’s photo management capabilities, something else you’ll appreciate about Lightroom is that it is a non-destructive editing program.
Worry-free Editing with Lightroom
Another key difference between Photoshop and Lightroom is that Lightroom is a non-destructive editor.
The program keeps a database of your edits, so you can go back to your original photo and change it up at a later time. With Photoshop, once you hit the ‘Save’ button, you’re committed.
Now that I’ve given you a quick overview of Lightroom’s features, let’s take a closer look at Photoshop.
While I’ve already mentioned that Photoshop Camera Raw and Lightroom share basic editing features, that’s where the similarity ends.
Photoshop started out as a digital photo editor, but over time has evolved into a beast of a software suite.
If you want to do advanced editing and retouching, Photoshop should be your software of choice.
The ability to use layers lets you work only on specific areas of a photo while leaving the others untouched.
Photoshop’s advanced graphic design capabilities mean that it is used not only by photographers but also by graphic designers, digital artists, social media marketers, architects and more.
This is why Photoshop is the best, most comprehensive (and probably the most complicated) editing program in the world.
When You Care About Perfection, Choose Photoshop
If Lightroom is the workhorse program for photo management and basic editing, Photoshop is the best tool for refining and perfecting single images.
Photoshop is also the best program for compositing images. (Compositing means to seamlessly combine images together to create a brand-new image.)
Here are a few of examples of compositing.
Replacing a grey, washed-out sky in a photo with a vibrant blue one, or changing out an unattractive background for one with a lot more appeal.
Compositing is also used a lot in portrait photography. I can’t tell you the number of times I’ve replaced the head of a non-smiling kid in a photo with a different photo where he has a perfect cheeky grin.
All in the name of creating a perfect family portrait!
But really, what Photoshop is most famous for is its retouching abilities.
The Photographer’s Choice for Retouching Images
Photoshop is a pixel-level editor. This means it has the power to transform the pixels of the image as it is edited.
We’ve all seen amazing Photoshop work where editors removed people from a scene, made chubby people thin, and even switched heads on subjects.
That’s pixel-level editing. Lightroom doesn’t have this capacity.
Photoshop also lets you zoom in and make fine adjustments with healing and cloning tools on a level you just can’t achieve with Lightroom.
So how would you use Lightroom and Photoshop together? Let’s go through an example editing session!
Sample Lightroom & Photoshop Editing Workflow
Say you just finished an epic photoshoot and shot 1000 images for a client.
Now you’re ready to cull all these images down to the very best ones from the shoot.
You import all those the images into Lightroom, then narrow those down into 300 images.
From there, you’d be super picky and cull these 300 images down to the 50 best images from the shoot. At this point, you could apply a Lightroom Preset, so all of your images have a consistent look.
Then you would send your top 50 over to your client and have them select their favorites.
Only after your clients select their favorites, are the images imported into Photoshop for final retouching.
A general rule of thumb is that any time your photos are to be printed in a large format, they need some extra TLC and refinement inside Photoshop.
When you enlarge photos for print, you see every little imperfection. So go the extra mile and do some touch-ups inside Photoshop.
I Don’t Use Photoshop for Every Photo Session
Personally, the only time I bring photos into Photoshop is when millions of people are going to see a specific image.
For example, because it’s going to be printed in a magazine or on an album cover and I want to zoom in on the details and give it a little more love.
Now, if your photos aren’t seen by millions (yet), that doesn’t mean you don’t ever need to use Photoshop.
I just wanted to put it in perspective for you by describing what a typical workflow is for me.
Do I need both Photoshop and Lightroom?
My honest answer to this question is, “It depends.”
I would encourage you to ask yourself some questions first before deciding:
- What kind of photography are you involved in or interested in?
- Are you a beginner, intermediate, or advanced photographer?
- Are you a hobbyist or a professional?
- What do you need from a photo editing program?
- What overall “look” are you going for in your photos?
- Do you want to edit quickly or on the go, or do you wish to perfect each and every image?
- Are you publishing or printing your images somewhere?
Choose the Editing Program that Best Fits Your Needs
Adobe makes both Lightroom and Photoshop.
But you don’t necessarily NEED to use both in your workflow.
You need to pick what best suits your needs, whether that means Lightroom, Photoshop, or both!
Regardless, I would almost argue that you DO you need Lightroom.
It’s really the best program for quick and professional photo editing – and there is no better program for managing and organizing your photo collection.
But I’ve got good news – you really don’t have to decide on which program is best for your editing needs!
Get Both Lightroom and Photoshop for the Same Price
If you decide on Lightroom, you might as well get Photoshop too for the same price!
Both programs are offered together in the Adobe Creative Cloud Photography Plan.
I have this exact plan and love it because I ALWAYS have the latest versions, plus it’s less than $10 a month.
Select the Photography plan that includes Lightroom Classic CC, Photoshop CC, Lightroom CC, and also get 20 GB of cloud storage for only $9.99/mo!
Want More Training?
I am doing a FREE editing training, where I’ll reveal my 5 Step Editing Recipe that every photographer should know.
In under 30 minutes, I’m going to show you how to edit your photos like a pro.
Yep, you heard me! After just 30 minutes with me, you’ll walk away a better (and more confident!) photo editor and photographer.